Maple Pecan Oat Flour Shortbread Cookies

I seem to say this a lot: This is the first time I have made this.  My approach to this blog is one of experimentation followed by relentless perfection…errrr….or something like that.  Of course I have my inventory of Julia’s Classic Recipes that I dust off and prepare from time to time, but for the most part, I have used this food blog as encouragement to try new things.  And I love it!

The other day I was in the mood for a cookie (surprise!) that is airy and subtle in flavor with a nice bite.  You won’t hear me say this very often regarding baked goods because (evidenced by my recent Oat Flour Brownie parade) I more often than not crave a sweet that is chocolaty, warm and gooey. Nevertheless, this renegade desire came creeping around the corner, and all I could think about was buttery shortbread.  Whoa, are you serious?  Shortbread makes me think of the cheesy (but very-nice-of-them) Christmas packages you get from your neighbor that he/she massed produced for friends and family and shortbread is still in their holiday baking package repertoire because someone told them 15 years ago that their shortbread was phenomenal (which may or may not have been a lie), so they held on to the tradition all these years, and yup, there’s the shortbread in my basket of holiday-neighbor-gift-goodies.

Does that sound rude?  Yes, yes it does, but that is truly how I felt about shortbread until, like a freight train, the burning need for a {somewhat healthified} homemade shortbread came screaming through my peripherals.  So I fired up the ol DuckDuckGo and DuckDuckGoed the crap out of shortbread recipes.  Here’s what I learned (by Golly, how simple these things are, I’m surprised that with my lazy nature I did not discover them sooner) they are made out of flour, sugar and butter.  Anytime an ingredient list can be spouted off in one breath with less than a handful of items, my interest is peaked.  From what I saw, flour and butter have a 2 : 1 ratio, so I started with that same ratio using oat flour, knowing I would probably need to modify the ratio since oat flour is not the same as all-purpose flour. . . not even close.  I also wanted to use pecans as part of the base of the recipe, almost in place of some of the flour so I knew I would need to ad-lib this part a little too.  What I ended up with is the recipe below, which made about 15 decent sized cookies, so you may want to double the recipe if you’re including shortbread in your holiday baked good give away for your neighbors next year 😉

Because I use maple syrup instead of cane sugar, and oat flour in place of all purpose, the cookies are more delicate than your run of the mill Keebler shortbread cookie.  So be prepared that you may experience a little crumble.  You can do a test round and if they are too crumbly, add more oat flour and/or chopped pecans.

Ingredients:

To Bake:

Preheat the oven to 325.  Make sure your butter is softened (leaving it out at room temperature for 10 minutes worked just fine for me).  If you are anything like me, you have the urge to melt the butter.  Don’t do it, I say! Cream the butter by itself using a KitchenAid or hand mixer.  I definitely recommend using a mixer as I think I would have lost patience had I done this by hand.  Add the vanilla, maple syrup and salt.  Add half of the oat flour and mix well, then the other half, mixing until all of the clumps smooth out and you’re left with a dry looking dough.  Add the chopped pecans and mix to incorporate.

Refrigerate the dough for at least an hour in an air-tight container (if you’re doing this ahead of time, you can refrigerate overnight).  After the dough has chilled, use a spoon to scoop out some dough; roll it into a ball and flatten it out.

These cookies stay in the same shape you mold them into, so you can get creative by rolling the dough out and using cookie cutters or forming shapes (I made a few hearts for Valentine’s Day).  Place cookies on a non-stick cookie sheet and bake in the oven for 15 minutes.  Remember, I bake at elevation so you may need to adjust the oven temperature and length of time if you happen to not live in the Sierra mountains. 😉  Enjoy and let me know if you found a better flour-to-butter ratio!

 

Share:

Never Miss a Post!

Comments

  1. Brandy

    This cookies are so delish! I toasted the pecans first. My dough was pretty gooey, even after some refrigeration. I plopped it on pans and flattened with fork, made just over 2 dozen. I baked them for 25 min and they were perfect! I also added 1/2 tsp poudre douce spice (Epicure).

    1. Julia Post author

      I’m so glad you enjoy the cookies! I’ve been meaning to re-make this recipe for AGES and you’ve inspired me to do so! xoxo

Comments are closed.